I see there was a topic on this back in 2018 but, here we go. There should be a way to non-lethally defeat somebody in PvP.
Subdual mode should be a toggle command. When fighting PCs in subdual mode, if you defeat them it should.
- Reduce them to 0 HP (so they appear as dead)
- After 60 seconds, return them to 1 HP
- Give them a five minute debuff that includes a slow, penalty to AC/AB, and penalty to stats. (to stop people from just abusing this to stand up and start throwing hands again)